Sunday, June 13, 2010

Can you tell me...

I was walking down to my office around 10 years back. I had just completed college and it was in the early days of my career. As I was enjoying the morning walk to my office, I was looking at various people doing various activities and getting ready to start their work. There was a construction site near by our office and I could see laborers doing manual labour. In India the ones doing menial, hard, physical jobs are considered to have lower strata in the society. The kind of jobs they do, earn them lesser too. Amongst those laborers was a hardworking, older looking man, whose dedication to work caught my eye. I paused to watch him for some time.

A lot of times, there are thoughts that come, hit you and go - all in a micro second and you know you will never ever be the same again. I remember thinking - what is the difference between him and any employee in my software industry? He does the same work that anyone in my office does, perhaps harder. He feels happy when good things happen to him and feels sad when he is hurt. He gets angry at things, when they do not work. Why the hell does he not enjoy the privileges that I or any one in my community does!

And then I remember thinking – Arent all human beings the same ? Who am I to differentiate between them ?

A small thought, a very common thought - but my life changed for ever. Never again in my life, could I ever command any one to do a menial job for me. This made life very difficult for me, because whether I met a carpenter, a labourer or a multi millionaire - I could no longer see any great difference in any one of them. They all looked the same to me. And it would leave them confused too - coz a man with high social position wouldn’t understand why I did not get awed by him - and a labourer would get confused as to why was I not maintaining a distance from him.

I did not know how to react to the levels and strata of society. And honestly speaking, I did not know where I stood in strata with respect to the different, unique, beautiful people in the society. Some were poor, some were rich. Some were highly accomplished, and some were not. But each one of them was beautiful and unique.

When we built our house - I personally took charge of the wood work in my house. There was a team of carpenters who came to work in our house and among them was an elderly carpenter. The other carpenters called him chacha ( uncle ). This man had a godly look on his face and I would just melt out of respect looking at his honest, hardworking face. And then one fine day, my Dad had come to visit me when the carpenters were at work. I looked at my dad and I looked at the old uncle - and I wondered, what is the difference between him and this old carpenter uncle?

I could not see any difference– thinking back, I still am not able to see any difference.
Can you tell me – what is the difference between the ones who have special status in the society and the ones who end up serving them?

How do you handle this social differentiation?

6 comments:

Shruti June 14, 2010 at 11:59 PM  

Veena, one of those thoughts that need to be penned once in a while. Thanks for writing it down. I have had the same thought countless times ever since I was a kid. Sharda ben who used to work in our house (from forever, I suppose) had two daughters who helped her out ever since they were 7-8 years old. And it always made me wonder, "what makes me privileged enough to have time to play every every day while they have to work so hard at something that is not even enjoyable?"

We Indians justify this on the basis of 'actions in past lives' and other vedantic jargon but even if that is true, it does not excuse us for thinking that we are somehow better than them. We are engineers and doctors today precisely because of the privileged childhoods, the leisure of time to study and all the tuitions we could afford to have.

My assessment is that two things need to happen - pay for hard labor needs to catch up the pay for an equal hour of educated work and there needs to be a huge improvement in accessibility to education and jobs for people with a lower economic status.

Veena June 15, 2010 at 9:47 AM  

@Shruti ,

My thoughts precisely.. ! Also agree on the last paragraph !

Nilu June 18, 2010 at 12:21 PM  

Hi Veena,

Very thought-provoking write-up. I too have struggled with this often. One incident is quite fresh. Only recently, when my MIL used to stay with us when Ananya arrived she used to tell me to give leftovers to our maid to eat. I used to struggle with this- if it is something that I wouldn't eat, why should I give it to the maid or anyone for that matter?

I've also observed different treatment being given to people based on how they are dressed or what vehicle they are driving in shops, restaurants, parks etc.

I do not think that just by increasing the hourly pay will improve things. Besides, it may also dilute the importance of education. The basic upbringing needs to change where children are taught that all human beings are equal. Only then things have a hope to change.

Vyshali Mahesh June 18, 2010 at 1:06 PM  

we all are different and compliment each other...only if we know it...

Vyshali Mahesh June 18, 2010 at 1:06 PM  

we all are different and compliment each other...only if we know it...

Veena June 18, 2010 at 4:37 PM  

@Neel,

Giving left overs to maids is something I just dont understand.. !

Good inputs on how things can be changed..

@Hema,
:)

  © Blogger templates Psi by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP